Working in regulatory affairs for an online retailer of adult-only nicotine products means navigating a landscape full of inconsistencies. In 2025, we are still debating online sales of adult-restricted products through a lens shaped by the dial-up internet era.
Nearly every other part of commerce has modernized. Other adult businesses have built seamless digital experiences, real-time verification systems and robust safeguards integrated into their infrastructure. Yet when it comes to nicotine retailers, policy and public discourse continue to rely on prohibition-era assumptions rather than contemporary systems.
This disconnect is especially striking when compared with how other regulated adult markets operate. Alcohol is routinely delivered to verified adults. In many states, cannabis functions as a compliance-driven, tech-forward industry. Sports betting platforms authenticate users within seconds using robust identity verification. These sectors are not defined by lax standards, but by sophisticated controls designed to manage risk at scale.
There is more to age verification across multiple industries that also applies to nicotine companies.
The Old ‘Click to Confirm You’re 21’ Button Is Not the Whole Story Anymore
There’s a widespread belief that underage buyers can slip into online adult marketplaces with one sneaky click. That might have been the story 20 years ago, but that’s not how the internet works today.
The ubiquitous “Click to confirm you’re 21” button, while still used, is just the beginning. The real security happens behind the scenes, and it’s a lot tougher than manual scans at checkout. According to Expert Insights, today’s responsible online retailers have implemented critical tools that maintain and restrict underage access.
These solutions run like multi-layered digital strongholds equipped with age and identity checks, biometric tools, digital verifications and database matching, which make the old pop-up look like a joke.
Prohibition Doesn’t Protect People, Good Systems Do
There’s a pattern across industries: banning products that adults want creates an unregulated, unverified and unsafe market. Whether it’s alcohol, gambling, cannabis or nicotine, here’s what a good system needs:
• Clear rules
• Transparent labeling
• Verified age and identity
• Strong enforcement
• Science driving the policy, not superstition
When those pieces are in place, adults are protected, minors are blocked and the black market stays small.
The Rolling Stone Culture Council is an invitation-only community for Influencers, Innovators and Creatives. Do I qualify?
So, Where Does That Leave Retailers and Other Regulated Businesses?
Adults navigating the market for any regulated products, whether it’s alcohol, cannabis, sports betting or nicotine, deserve a system built around reality, not outdated assumptions. Retailers and manufacturers play a crucial role in ensuring the marketplace is safe, compliant and aligned with scientific evidence. That means businesses need to:
• Ensure that adequate protections are in place to prevent their business from attracting underage customers.
• Advocate for a unified and common-sense approach to regulating all adult-only products.
• Stay informed about emerging science and educate your stakeholders on the latest technology and research.
• Stay engaged in policy discussions and advocate for policies that promote anti-prohibition measures.
A Regulatory Insider’s View: We’re Overdue for an Update
The technology is ready. Adults already expect transparency, verification and consistency. The gaps we see aren’t a matter of capability but of cultural lag.
We need to update our approach to thinking, talking and legislating around adult products online. Consumers don’t need to be nudged toward anything. They deserve systems designed for the world they actually live in.
The sooner our cultural reflexes catch up to reality, the sooner we’ll stop trying to solve modern problems with archaic fears and solutions.
link